It gets late early out there. - Yogi Berra
I'm a little late to this controversy, but I've never let a little mold put me off of anything…
On December 8th, Tommy Craggs wrote an article in Slate titled "What John Wooden Gets Wrong About Basketball". Anyone who has read this site knows I have great admiration for the man. But I'm not enough of a basketball savant to judge his basketball knowledge. As a rec league player and, despite my height, perennial late round pick, I had to rely on the fact that the man won 10 NCAA titles and 16 Conference titles as a coach, and as a player he was a three time All-American and Player of the Year in 1932. He is also one of three people inducted into the Basketball Hall of Fame as a player and as a coach. With that resume, I figured he was pretty good at the basketball in addition to understanding how to train and motivate people. But that's just me with my limited understanding of basketball.
I do like to read differenct perspectives. I like to know why people believe different things, maybe learn something I didn't know which could change my perspective on a person or issue. So when I saw the title of Craggs' article I thought I'd give it a try. After all, a guy that last coached when I was in 4th grade probably has been proven wrong about a thing or two.
But my hope for enlightenment was shot in the fourth paragraph. When I read this passage I knew the article wasn't about Wooden or his philosophy as much as it was a chance for a writer to get noticed by taking a shot at a 96 year old man.
But it's time we retire this notion of Wooden as basketball's wise old man and see his legacy for what it is: a triumph of rigidity, bureaucracy, paternalism, and anal retentiveness.
Wow, that's a lot of things for one man to get wrong and still be admired at 96! So what is Craggs' evidence for the indictment?
Wooden was a relentless taskmaster who counted discipline among the game's most important tenets. He had a hand in everything, from his players' grooming habits down to the wool content of their socks (50 percent). In one incredible passage in his coaching textbook, Practical Modern Basketball, Wooden details the Bruins' eating routine: "The meal usually consists of a ten-to-twelve-ounce steak broiled medium or an equivalent portion of lean roast beef, a small baked potato, a green vegetable, three pieces of celery, four small slices of melba toast, some honey, hot tea, and a dish of fruit cocktail.
Taskmaster indeed… I don't know a college coach worth his shoe contract who isn't concerned about his athlete's feet and doesn't consult a nutritionist. Wooden didn't have the benefit of a Nike research center or Gatorade Training center. He had to figure out what kept his athletes from getting blisters and what food gave them the strength to play the game as he taught it. Craggs may not like the certainty that Wooden had about what was right, but if the noted conformist Bill Walton could survive then Wooden's UCLA was probably a little looser than Stalin's Russia.
John Wooden is the father of modern basketball because he taught an up-tempo, attacking game. It was revolutionary at the time and required each player to perform his specific task perfectly. Yes he insisted his players do things a particular way — because that way worked! Coaching is about making the whole better than the sum of it's parts. Regardless of the titles, there can be no argument that John Wooden was very good at doing that.
Bum Phillips , former NFL Houston Oilers head coach, once said about Don Shula , the legendary NFL Miami Dophins Coach, "He'll take his and beat your's, then he'll take your's and beat his". The same is true of John Wooden. He had tremendous talent at UCLA, but there were other teams with great talent too. John Wooden used his discipline, knowledge and talent to beat them all. Sounds like an American success story to me…